GirlChat #455866
Re: I HATE hearing news like this....
Posted by lgsinmyheart on 2008-November-21 19:32:35 EST, Friday
In reply to Re: I HATE hearing news like this.... posted by Seth on 2008-November-21 07:11:27 EST, Friday
Even most libertarians would disagree with this ridiculous notion. Technically neither the state nor parents own children. They are either under the stewardship of their parents/guardians or they are wards of the state, with the state being their steward.
That's in theory.
In real laws, children are actually treated as property of either. Don't believe me?? Check your codes!! Specifics may vary, sometimes take opposite positions in different countries, but it's true everywhere in the world.
In other words, even parents/the state, while they have a lot of power over kids, cannot violate laws that pertain to their welfare.
Are you very very sure???
'cause that's just not what's happening...
If you do not treat children as property (which you say you do not), then what you claim to believe runs counter to what you practice, making you a hypocrite or ineffective, or both.
Tu quoque.
You are showing you can contradict Goethe without fallacious resource; do it and you'll be all the stronger for that.
This post is archived, preventing any new replies.
Responses
- Re: I HATE hearing news like this.... - Seth on 2008-November-21 20:30:51 EST, Friday - (0 / 0 / 1)
- Re: I HATE hearing news like this.... - Goethe on 2008-November-22 09:38:24 EST, Saturday - (0 / 0 / 0)