GirlChat #548713
They DID choose these people
Posted by Markaba on 2012-January-25 21:20:23 EST, Wednesday
In reply to kids need right to choose caretakers posted by Baldur on 2012-January-25 08:37:48 EST, Wednesday
"For stepfathers and stepbrothers, there is no genetic cost at all. It is no surprise, then, that between half and three-quarters of all reported incest cases are between stepfathers and stepdaughters, most of them initiated by the stepfather." (Stephen Pinker, How the Mind Works, pg. 458)
Moreover, as Pinker goes on to say, blood relatives who do commit incest almost never grow up together (thus muting or overcoming the Westermarck Effect.)
That said, I agree that kids' situation needs to be more fluid, but given what we know about stepparents/caretakers vs. real parents, this could potentially make a situation worse for kids, so there has to be more to it than just kids being able to choose whom they live with. Kids need stability too, and we don't want them bouncing around from one abusive prick to the next or winding up on the streets. We need to be able to verify that the situation is okay for kids. I propose a tradeoff here: society allows kids more freedom in general, but with kids who opt to go out of their parental homes, the state has to look in on those kids as a matter of course every so often. Of course, that would only apply to children who had not yet emancipated themselves via the Epstein mechanisms. Giving kids freedom to go where they choose can solve some problems, but it could also be a huge pain in the ass and make the situation much worse for kids, as often happens with kids who run away from home.
This post is archived, preventing any new replies.
Responses
- Re: They DID choose these people - qtns2di4 on 2012-January-26 06:25:27 EST, Thursday - (1 / 0 / 0)
- OT from your post but... - AK47 on 2012-January-25 21:43:36 EST, Wednesday - (0 / 0 / 2)
- Re: OT from your post but... - Markaba on 2012-January-25 22:14:58 EST, Wednesday - (1 / 0 / 1)
- Re: OT from your post but... - AK47 on 2012-January-25 22:39:51 EST, Wednesday - (0 / 0 / 0)
- Re: OT from your post but... - Markaba on 2012-January-25 22:14:58 EST, Wednesday - (1 / 0 / 1)
- Re: They DID choose these people - kratt on 2012-January-25 21:28:21 EST, Wednesday - (0 / 0 / 1)
- Re: They DID choose these people - Markaba on 2012-January-25 21:56:49 EST, Wednesday - (1 / 0 / 0)