GirlChat #555028


Re: More important, also

Posted by Markaba on 2012-May-19 05:01:51 EDT, Saturday
In reply to More important, also posted by qtns2di4 on 2012-May-19 04:20:15 EDT, Saturday

  Views: 0    Likes: 0     
Roughly speaking, there is some overlap between the cultures that practice child marriage and those that practice female abortion. I know the overlap is not complete; that Koreans practice the latter only and Arabs the former only. But that is not the case in the Subcontinent, where most child marriage and most female abortion happen. You would think that if girl welfare really was a goal, there should be at least the same focus on saving their lifestyle at 12 years than their lives at 12 weeks. Yet "women rights advocates" save all their rage against marrying girls and have nothing to say about killing girls. Sorry but that is not only hypocritical, but pretty much bares that the real issue they have is with the sex, not with girl welfare or rights. Same as, in other countries, "saving" girls from prostitution (or labor generally) is about keeping them dependent, not about improving their lives.

This need not even be an argument for child marriage, at that. In itself it isn't. It's only an argument against those who are fighting child marriage.


It's not even that. You know very well you are begging the question here, since your argument hinges on the acceptance of fetuses as full-fledged human beings with the same rights as the born, which is at the very heart of the abortion debate. In other words, you are arguing from the perspective 'the unborn are people' is a given, when it is not.


This post is archived, preventing any new replies.

Responses